8 in 10 websites covered by Spain’s Accessibility Law fail a basic accessibility test
Since 28 June 2025, banks, telecom operators, airlines, online shops and video platforms selling to consumers in Spain must have accessible websites. This is required by Law 11/2023, which brings the European Accessibility Act into Spanish law.
Almost a year and a half later, we wanted to see how the most visited websites in those sectors are doing. We took the 10 most visited in each sector, 60 in total, and ran an automated accessibility test on their home pages: the kind of check any team can run for free in a few seconds.
The result: 49 of the 60 websites fail. They have at least one error that blocks or hinders people who browse with a screen reader, with the keyboard, with voice control or with tired eyes.
The result at a glance
Each dot is one of the 60 websites tested. In blue, those with at least one detectable error.
49 of 60 websites have detectable accessibility errors (82%)
Websites with at least one critical error, as classified by the testing tool itself.
25 of 60 have at least one critical error (42%)
What we tested
The law does not cover every website, only specific consumer services. We took the six service sectors it lists and, in each one, the 10 most visited websites in Spain.
| Sector | Websites tested |
|---|---|
| Banking | Banco Sabadell, BBVA, CaixaBank, Banco Santander, Bankinter, Ibercaja, Openbank, Cajamar, Laboral Kutxa, Revolut |
| Telecoms | Orange, Vodafone, Movistar, DIGI, Lowi, O2, Yoigo, Jazztel, Simyo, MásMóvil |
| Audiovisual platforms | Netflix, Prime Video, Disney+, RTVE Play, DAZN, 3Cat, Movistar Plus+, Atresplayer, Filmin, HBO Max |
| Passenger transport | Ryanair, Iberia, Renfe, Vueling, Alsa, Wizz Air, Volotea, Air Europa, Ouigo, LEVEL |
| E-commerce | AliExpress, Shein, IKEA, Amazon, Leroy Merlin, Zara, Wallapop, El Corte Inglés, Mango, Vinted |
| E-books | Scribd, Casa del Libro, Kobo, Todos tus libros, Audible, Storytel, Everand, Bookmate, 24symbols, Lektu |
We measured popularity with public data: the country ranking of the Chrome UX Report (the sites Chrome users in Spain visit most) and, to break ties, the Tranco ranking. The details are in the methodology at the end of the article.
We tested only the home page, as the reference study in the United States does (the WebAIM Million). It is the front door: if there are barriers there, the rest of the journey is unlikely to be better.
Results by sector: transport comes last
No sector is spared, but the differences are large. In passenger transport, all 10 websites tested (airlines, trains and buses) have errors. In banking, 4 of 10 have none.
Websites with accessibility errors, by sector
Websites with at least one detectable error (out of 10 tested)
Average errors detected per website
Transport is not only the one sector where every website fails: it also has the most errors, 28 per website on average. That is bad news for a service many disabled people need to handle on their own, such as buying a ticket, checking a timetable or checking in.
Banking comes off best: 4 errors on average, and 6 of its 10 websites have one error or none.
| Sector | Websites with errors | Websites with critical errors | Average errors | Websites without errors |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Passenger transport | 10 of 10 | 6 | 28 | None |
| E-commerce | 9 of 10 | 4 | 21.2 | Mango |
| Telecoms | 9 of 10 | 5 | 18.2 | Movistar |
| Audiovisual platforms | 8 of 10 | 4 | 8.5 | 3Cat, HBO Max |
| E-books | 7 of 10 | 4 | 13.2 | Scribd, Everand, Storytel |
| Banking | 6 of 10 | 2 | 4 | Banco Sabadell, BBVA, CaixaBank, Laboral Kutxa |
| Total | 49 of 60 | 25 | 15.5 | 11 websites |
The most common errors
Across the 60 websites we found 931 errors of 26 different types. But almost everything comes down to a few, and none of them is hard to fix.
The 7 most common errors
Share of the 60 websites with each error at least once
Behind each of these technical names is a real person who gets shut out:
47% of websites
The button’s name doesn’t match what you see
The button says "Search flights", but in the code it is called, for example, "Send". A voice-control user says what they see on screen, and the button does not respond.
43% of websites
Low-contrast text
Light grey on white, white on light orange. Hard to read with low vision, with tired eyes or simply on a phone in the sun.
25% of websites
Buttons too small or too close together
WCAG 2.2 asks for at least 24 × 24 pixels per target. Below that, people with a tremor or limited hand precision tap the wrong thing.
25% of websites
Links without a name
An icon with no text. The screen reader just says "link", and a blind user has no idea where it goes.
18% of websites
Zoom blocked on mobile
The page stops you from pinching to zoom. For anyone who needs bigger text, that is a closed door.
12% of websites
Images without alt text
Products, banners and offers that do not exist for a screen reader. It is also an SEO problem: Google cannot tell what they show either.
This is not a small group. According to the latest disability survey by Spain’s statistics institute INE (EDAD 2020), 4.38 million people living in private households in Spain have some form of disability, 9.5% of the population. And barriers of contrast, size or zoom also affect many older people who do not consider themselves disabled.
Not just a few stray errors
A website with one minor failure is not the same as one with 100. So we also looked at how many errors each website has.
How many errors each website has
Number of websites (of 60) by errors detected on the home page
27 websites have 5 errors or fewer: with a little work they could pass. At the other end, 14 websites have more than 20 errors, and 4 have more than 50. That is no longer an oversight but a design that did not take accessibility into account from the start.
What this study does (and does not) say
We want to be precise, because it is easy to read too much into it:
- It is an automated test. Automated tools find only part of accessibility problems. A website with no errors in this test may have others that only show up in manual testing. The real picture is therefore worse than what we show.
- It covers only the home page. Checkout forms, customer areas and payment flows were not tested.
- It is not a legal audit. Conformity with the law is assessed against the EN 301 549 standard with a full review, and the law itself allows transition periods and exceptions. This study measures detectable barriers; it does not say which company complies and which does not.
- It is not directly comparable with the United States. The WebAIM Million 2026 report found detectable errors on 95.9% of the world’s million most visited home pages. It uses another tool (WAVE) and a very different sample, so our 82% does not mean Spain is “better”: our 60 websites belong to large companies with teams and budgets.
That is exactly why the figure stands out. These are the best-resourced companies in their sectors, legally required to be accessible for over a year, and 8 in 10 fail a free test that takes seconds.
It can be done: the 11 websites that passed
Banco Sabadell, BBVA, CaixaBank, Laboral Kutxa, Movistar, 3Cat, HBO Max, Mango, Scribd, Everand and Storytel had no detectable errors on their home pages. Some are large, complex websites with thousands of elements and a lot of dynamic content. Complexity is no excuse.
What a company can do
If your company is in one of these sectors, or you simply want everyone to be able to use your website, this is the order we recommend:
Where to start
Free automated test of your main pages with axe DevTools or Lighthouse. Fix what repeats first: contrast and the names of buttons and links.
Manual test: go through buying or signing up using only the keyboard, with a screen reader and at 200% zoom.
Fix it in the design system, not page by page: colours, minimum button size and components with accessible names.
Check every release: an automated test on each release stops the errors from coming back.
Many of these fixes also help SEO: alt text on images, descriptive link text, a declared page language and a clear structure. A website a screen reader understands is usually one Google understands too. If you want to see the rest of what Google looks at, start with the guide to what SEO is or run your website through the free SEO audit. And if you would rather have a full review done by a person, that is what we do in the SEO audit.
Methodology
- Sectors: the services in article 2.2 of Law 11/2023: electronic communications, access to audiovisual media services, passenger transport (air, rail, bus and waterborne), consumer banking, e-books and e-commerce.
- Sample: for each sector we listed companies offering the service to consumers in Spain and ranked them by popularity in Spain according to the Chrome UX Report (October 2026). Because that ranking groups sites into bands, we broke ties with the Tranco ranking. We took the top 10 in each sector.
- Exclusions: three websites could not be tested and were replaced by the next one on the list. Two blocked automated testing and one has no version for Spain.
- Page tested: the home page of the Spanish version, as a visitor from Spain sees it, in a desktop browser, without interacting with it (cookie banners are tested as they appear).
- Tool: axe-core 4.14, the open-source engine also used by Lighthouse and many professional tools, with the WCAG 2.0, 2.1 and 2.2 rules at levels A and AA. We counted only confirmed errors, not the cases the tool flags for manual review.
- What we counted: a website “fails” if it has at least one error. “Errors” are the number of page elements that break a rule. Severity (critical, serious, moderate) is as assigned by axe-core.
- Date: November 2026. Websites change often, so the results reflect the day of the test.
Frequently asked questions
Which websites must be accessible under Law 11/2023?
Law 11/2023 transposes the European Accessibility Act into Spanish law. Since 28 June 2025 it applies to companies offering consumers electronic communications, access to audiovisual media services, air, bus, rail and waterborne passenger transport, consumer banking, e-books and e-commerce. Microenterprises providing services are exempt, and some cases have transition periods.
Does failing this test mean breaking the law?
Not necessarily. The test finds errors against the WCAG guidelines, which are the technical basis of the European standard EN 301 549. Legal conformity is assessed with a full audit, and the law allows exceptions and transition periods. Our study measures detectable barriers; it makes no legal judgement about any company.
Why don’t you publish which websites had the most errors?
Because the study is about the state of each sector, not about singling out companies. An automated test of a home page is not enough to judge a whole website. We do name the websites that had no errors at all, to show that it can be done.
How can I check my own website’s accessibility?
A free first step is to run axe DevTools or Lighthouse (in Chrome, Lighthouse tab, Accessibility category) on your main pages. Then you need manual checks: use the site with the keyboard only, with a screen reader and at 200% zoom. Automated tools find only part of the problems.
Does accessibility affect SEO?
Indirectly, yes. Several accessibility fixes are also good SEO practice: alt text on images, descriptive link text, a declared page language and a clear heading structure. Google does not use accessibility as a direct ranking factor, but a site that is easier to use and understand is also easier for search engines.
Sources
- BOE: Law 11/2023 of 8 May (accessibility of certain products and services), in Spanish
- WebAIM: The WebAIM Million (2026)
- W3C: Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) 2.2
- Deque: axe-core accessibility testing engine
- INE: Survey on Disability, Personal Autonomy and Dependency (EDAD 2020), in Spanish
- Chrome UX Report: popularity lists by country
- Tranco: a research-oriented domain popularity ranking
Related free tools
Free 10-page SEO audit →
Checks the home page and nine more: titles, descriptions, H1, canonical, hreflang, structured data, robots.txt, sitemap, broken links and speed. Score from 0 to 100.
Schema (JSON-LD) generator →
Create structured data of 15 types (local business, article, product, event, recipe, job…) or analyze a page and get its corrected schema.
Want to know what your website needs? Ask for a free mini-audit: we send you a short written report and go through it on a call.
Ask for your free mini-auditLast updated: